The Star Beacon; Ashtabula, Ohio

World, nation, state

November 11, 2012

Fact check: Would tax hike on wealthy kill 700,000 jobs?

"The president wants to raise taxes on the wealthiest 2 percent of Americans. But what that does is it net loses 700,000 more American jobs that are really from people who need those jobs."

— Rep. Pete Sessions, R-Texas, on Fox News, Nov. 8

"According to Ernst & Young, raising the top rates would destroy nearly 700,000 jobs in our country."

— House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, Nov. 9

- - - - -

The presidential election is over. Time to get ready for the fiscal cliff!

The fiscal cliff is the looming end-of-the-year expiration of the Bush-era tax cuts and the automatic spending cuts mandated by the Budget Control Act. The double whammy would likely sink the economy, though Democrats and Republicans disagree on the best approach for resolving the problem.

For his part, President Barack Obama has long urged retaining the Bush tax cuts for workers making less than $250,000, but letting tax rates (and some other provisions) rise for the wealthiest Americans. Republicans have opposed this, in part because they say it would harm small businesses that organize themselves so earnings or losses are passed though to the shareholders — who then are taxed at the individual tax rate.

Rep. Pete Sessions, however, went further and claimed on Thursday that hundreds of thousands of people would lose their jobs if Obama's proposed tax increase went into effect. And Boehner on Friday repeated the claim at a news conference. What's the math behind this claim?

The Facts

According to an aide, Sessions obtained his figure from a study prepared last year by two economists at Ernst & Young for the Independent Community Bankers of America, the National Federation of Independent Business, the S Corporation Association and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce — all opponents of the president's agenda.

That might be the first clue that this is potentially not a neutral document. One of the authors is also a former official in George W. Bush's Treasury Department.

The study is titled "Long-run macroeconomic impact of increasing tax rates on high-income taxpayers in 2013."

In other words, this is not an immediate impact, but the "long run." You have to dig into the endnotes on page 22 to find a definition of long run: "For models of this type, roughly two-third to three-quarters of the long-run effect is reached within a decade."

Oh. So, even if one accepts the assumptions in this model — a big "if" — it still means that the loss of 700,000 jobs would not come in the first year, or by the end of Obama's second term, or even a decade from now. Yet Sessions says the jobs would be taken "from people who need those jobs," suggesting it would have an immediate effect.

Moreover, while 700,000 jobs sounds like a lot, it actually translates into one-half of 1 percent of total employment. Given that this is a long-term prediction, there is certainly a lot of room for error. So much is dependent on the assumptions in the model.

There is also another revealing endnote: "Using the additional revenue to reduce the deficit is not modeled."

That means the analysts did not even study the effect of Obama's stated purpose for raising taxes; the 700,000 figure assumes that the revenue raised from the tax increase would be used for increased government spending. Yet presumably any deal on fixing the fiscal cliff would result in a lower federal deficit, since all sides agree they have that goal.

Indeed, there are also long-term effects from permanently extending the tax cuts without cutting the deficit. This is what the Congressional Budget Office said in 2010, after studying the impact of full, partial or temporary extensions of tax cuts: "The permanent extensions of the tax cuts would have much larger negative effects in the long term than the temporary extensions because the amount of additional government debt would be so much larger."

In other words, focusing just one variable — an increase in taxes — is a bit simplistic. By itself, raising taxes likely leads to a reduction in employment. But the use of that additional revenue over the long term is also important — such as whether it is used to reduce budget deficits or boost government spending.

- - - - -

Sessions is able to point to a study (though he stated the 700,000 figure as a fact), but on several levels his claim is misleading.

First, the study was underwritten by the White House's opponents. Second, the study never examined what Obama claims he will do with the revenue — dedicate it to deficit reduction. And finally, the total figure is so "long term" — more than 10 years away — that it is absurd to suggest those jobs would be lost in the near term.

As for Boehner, he did attribute the figure to Ernst & Young, but he went even further in saying the top rates would "destroy" 700,000 jobs. As we said, that is simply absurd.

- - -

Read The Fact Checker: the Truth Behind the Rhetoric, at www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/fact-checker

Text Only
World, nation, state
  • Oklahoma Tornado Face_Lind.jpg Distraught mom becomes face of Oklahoma storm

    A massive tornado was carving its way through town. There was no time to hesitate. LaTisha Garcia had to get to her children.

    May 24, 2013 1 Photo 1 Story

  • Man shot by FBI had spoken with bombing suspect

    A Chechen immigrant shot to death in central Florida after an altercation with an FBI agent had several ties to that of one of the Boston Marathon bombing suspects who authorities were questioning him about at the time.

    May 24, 2013

  • Jurors deadlock on Jodi Arias penalty; retrial set

    Jurors who spent five months determining Jodi Arias’ fate couldn’t decide whether she should get life in prison or die for murdering her boyfriend, sending prosecutors back to the drawing board to rehash the shocking case of sex, lies and violence to another 12 people.

    May 24, 2013

  • Big U.S. cities showing strong growth

    Urban renewal? New census estimates show that most of the nation’s largest cities further enhanced their allure last year, posting strong population growth for a second straight year.

    May 24, 2013

  • Missing Women Found_Lind.jpg Cleveland kidnap case hero gets year of free McDonald’s

    The man who famously put down his Big Mac to help rescue three women held captive for years in a Cleveland house will get free McDonald’s for the next year, a company spokeswoman confirmed Thursday.

    May 24, 2013 1 Photo

  • Boy Scouts approve plan to accept openly gay youth

    The Boy Scouts of America threw open its ranks Thursday to gay Scouts but not gay Scout leaders — a fiercely contested compromise that some warned could fracture the organization and lead to mass defections of members and donors.
     

    May 24, 2013

  • Ohio injection well operator fights state action

    A northeast Ohio injection-well operator whose former senior officer faces federal charges of violating the Clean Water Act told a state regulatory panel Wednesday that the company can’t be blamed for the acts of “a bad person.”

    May 24, 2013

  • Man shot to death while questioned in Boston probe

    A Chechen immigrant was shot to death by authorities early Wednesday after he turned violent while being questioned about his ties to one of the Boston Marathon bombing suspects, officials said.
     

    May 23, 2013

  • Jury in Arias trial adjourns after impasse

    Jurors in the Jodi Arias murder trial said Wednesday they were unable to reach a unanimous verdict on whether she should be sentenced to life in prison or death for killing her one-time boyfriend, prompting the judge to instruct them to keep trying.
     

    May 23, 2013

  • More than 50 hurt when Indiana school buses have chain-reaction crash

    A school bus slammed into the back of another one Wednesday afternoon, setting off a chain-reaction crash involving four buses in northern Indiana, leaving about 50 middle and high students with non-serious injuries and one driver seriously injured.
     

    May 23, 2013

Community Calendar
Loading…
Events by eviesays.com
House Ads
Parade
Magazine

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
Andover Fire 1955
AP Video