The Star Beacon; Ashtabula, Ohio

Local News

October 9, 2008

Medical expert doubts girl lied about rape

Experts talked with suspected victim at Youngstown center

JEFFERSON — Two medical experts from the Tri-County Child Advocacy Center in Youngstown spent several hours testifying for the state Thursday in the Timothy Poling rape trial, with one expert saying it is doubtful the alleged victim lied.

The primary witnesses were Dr. Paul McPherson, the center’s medical director since 2007, and Janet Gorsuch, , a TCCAC nurse practitioner.

Both testified that Poling was identified as the accused molester after hearing the 11-year-old girl’s statements taken on Dec. 5, 2005. According to Gorsuch’s report, the child allegedly was molested sexually from April 2003 to November 2005.

The girl is the granddaughter of Poling’s live-in girlfriend, Debbie Cunningham. The girl would visit the Cunningham-Poling home in Pierpont Township at least once a month on weekends during those three years.

Poling, 40, of Dorset Township is charged with two counts of rape and 25 counts of gross sexual imposition.

Thursday’s court session was long, ending at 5 p.m. There were frequent jury recesses to settle legal motions between attorneys for both sides. Only a few people were in the gallery, including the girl’s mother.

Assistant county prosecutors Margaret Draper and Gene Barrett represent the state in the criminal trial. The defendant is represented by attorney David Per Due of Madison.

County Sheriff’s Deputy Michael Rose with the Ashtabula County Children Services Board testified he conducted the initial criminal investigation. Rose said because of the one-month delay in reporting the sex crimes, there was no DNA evidence linking Poling to them.

Per Due did not cross-examine Rose.

The prosecutors rested their case following Rose’s testimony.

After excusing the jury, presiding Common Pleas Court Judge Ronald Vettel heard arguments from Draper and Per Due over several prosecution exhibits to be submitted. Vettel finally allowed only Gorsuch’s report to be submitted as a court exhibit for any appeals purposes.

The trial continues at 1 p.m. today with more defense witnesses expected to testify.

During Thursday’s proceedings, McPherson and Gorsuch spoke extensively of their expert credentials along with services available at the advocacy center for children physically and sexually abused, from newborns to 18 years.

McPherson is also a pediatrician for Akron Children’s Hospital. He testified of having reviewed the medical history and statements the girl gave to Gorsuch. The child’s mother, Chastity Eichele, had been referred to the center by Ashtabula County Children Services officials, McPherson said.

Asked by Draper whether a child of 4, 5 or 6 years of age can remember dates well, McPherson told the jury that it all depends on the child’s cognitive development.

The doctor contends a child under 6 or 7 years may be able to talk about “events happening” but cannot always provide specific dates.

“As adults, we can recall details better,” he said.

McPherson told the jury that the vast majority of sexually abused children will delay disclosing to anyone what occurred. They could be ashamed or even fearful, he said.

Under cross-examination, Per Due asked McPherson whether children make up things to get attention or even lie. McPherson said sometimes they do but disagreed in this case that the girl has lied.

Referring to Gorsuch’s report, McPherson detailed that Poling used “grooming techniques” to gain trust of the girl. The defendant played games or would think up tricks, the girl told Gorsuch.

Gorsuch testified the center uses a team approach in interviewing abused children, so as to not subject the children to repeating their statements over and over to multiple staff members.

Gorsuch related she personally took the girl’s medical history, conducted the child’s physical examination and took more statements from both the child and her mother.

Poling is referred to as “Grandpa Tim” by the girl in Gorsuch’s report.

Gorsuch testified the physical exam findings were “consistent with sexual abuse,” although no vaginal penetration was apparent.

Per Due’s first defense witness was Janet Persichetti of Sevierville, Tenn., a former girlfriend of Debbie Cunningham’s son, Neil, the girl’s father. Persichetti said she was a friend of Poling and Cunningham from 2002 to 2005. She spoke of having visited frequently their Pierpont Township home with her now-13-year-old daughter, Jenna Williams, who also testified.

Persichetti testified she never saw Poling touch the girl or her daughter improperly. Persichetti and her daughter moved to Tennessee in 2007.

A third defense witness was Cheryl Scruton, former teacher at Cranesville Christian Academy in Cranesville, Pa., who was the alleged victim’s teacher in the first and second grades. Scruton described the girl as “friendly and got good grades.” The girl sometimes needed more attention than the other students, she said.

Text Only
Local News
  • Six ready to interview for Buckeye’s super job

    The Buckeye Local Board of Education will conduct interviews with six superintendent hopefuls next week, said Board President Jacqueline Hillyer.

    May 25, 2012

  • fridaySchool Shooting Ohio.jpg Shooting suspect to be tried as adult

    A 17-year-old will be tried as an adult in the school shooting deaths of three students, a juvenile court judge ruled Thursday after hearing a sheriff’s deputy describe how the teen wore a T-shirt with the word “Killer” and admitted shooting people.

    May 25, 2012 1 Photo

  • Ohio EPA takes AIM at site of hazardous wastes

     Ohio Environmental Protection Agency staff members returned this week to the site of the now-bankrupt Ashtabula Iron and Metal on West 30th Street to take samples of the unknown liquids and analyze hazardous wastes, asbestos and other potential health and environmental concerns.

    May 25, 2012

  • Commissioners look at selling nursing beds

    Commissioners have retained the services of a law firm that specializes in the sale of excess nursing home beds as the board looks at ways to raise additional revenues.

    May 25, 2012

  • Conneaut looks at demolition funds

    The city is making preparations to secure its share of nearly $692,000 in demolition funds expected to be Ashtabula County’s portion of a multi-billion dollar settlement with national mortgage lenders.

    May 25, 2012

  • MT Friday Key bank .jpg Volunteers get more help than needed at rescue spot

     Despite their good intentions, Edward and Mary proved more hindrance than help to the Conneaut KeyBank employees lending a helping hand Thursday to a farm animal rescue operation in Kingsville Township.

    May 25, 2012 1 Photo

  • wd friday lakeside grad 2 .jpg 220 graduate at Lakeside

    Thursday night was a time of pomp, circumstance and smiles as 220 seniors graduated from Lakeside High School.

    May 25, 2012 2 Photos

  • Lost money?

    There is no map, and “X” may not mark the spot, but hundreds of Ashtabula County residents may have unclaimed cash ready and waiting for them through the Ohio Department of Commerce.

    May 25, 2012

  • Lane to be tried as adult in Chardon High shooting

    A 17-year-old boy will be tried as an adult in the school shooting deaths of three students, a juvenile court judge ruled Thursday.

    May 24, 2012

  • Happy Hearts Graduation Happy Hearts School holds commencement for its Class of 2012

     As commencement exercises go in Ashtabula County, the one at Happy Hearts School was small, with just five students.

    May 24, 2012 3 Photos

Community Calendar
Loading…
Events by eviesays.com
House Ads
AP Video